The concept of subcreation, as articulated by J.R.R. Tolkien, refers to the creative process through which humans craft new worlds, stories, and art that reflect and complement the divine act of creation. Tolkien, a philologist and scholar, emphasized that while God is the ultimate Creator, humans, made in His image, are called to engage in subcreation, a notion he explored in his influential essay "On Fairy-Stories."
This philosophy underpins much of his renowned fantasy literature, including The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, which have had a lasting impact on the genre and continue to inspire countless authors and creators.
Tolkien's subcreation is intricately linked to his world-building practices, wherein he created the richly detailed universe of Middle-earth. This setting not only serves as a backdrop for his narratives but also reflects profound moral and philosophical themes, such as the struggle between good and evil, the nature of heroism, and the complexities of moral agency. His invention of languages, including Sindarin and Quenya, enhances the cultural depth of his works, allowing for a more immersive experience for readers and contributing to the authenticity of his fictional races and histories.
Tolkien's exploration of subcreation also invites discourse on the moral implications of artistic expression. He viewed the act of creating as a form of worship that celebrates the divine spark within humanity, raising questions about the nature of creativity, humility, and the relationship between the creator and the created. Critics have debated the potential for pride in the subcreator's role and how this interacts with the idea of sanctified creativity, thus highlighting a nuanced understanding of artistic responsibility within Tolkien's framework.
Ultimately, Tolkien's legacy as a subcreator and world-builder is not merely a testament to his storytelling abilities, but also a philosophical exploration of creativity that encourages readers to reflect on their own lives and the moral choices they face. His works serve as a profound reminder of the transformative power of imagination and the enduring significance of the narratives we craft.
Background
J.R.R. Tolkien, renowned for his monumental contributions to fantasy literature, was not only a writer but also a philologist and scholar deeply engaged in the intricacies of language and mythology. His scholarly background played a critical role in shaping his fictional worlds, particularly through his concept of "subcreation," which he articulated in his essay "On Fairy-Stories." Tolkien posited that while God is the sole Creator, humans, made in His image, are called to subcreate—crafting new worlds and stories within the framework of the original creation. This perspective influenced not just the content of his works, but also their structure and themes.
Tolkien's approach to world-building involved careful attention to language, drawing inspiration from various linguistic movements that emerged around the turn of the 20th century. Scholars note that Tolkien found aesthetic pleasure in the sound patterns of languages, which led him to create intricate linguistic systems for his fictional races, including Elves, Dwarves, and Men. His passion for languages was evident in his crafting of multiple dialects and tongues within Middle-earth, enriching the cultural backdrop of his narratives.
Moreover, Tolkien's personal experiences and historical context significantly shaped his literary output. Having lived through two world wars and witnessed the profound impacts of human conflict and moral ambiguity, his works often reflect a deep moral examination of good versus evil. This thematic exploration is central to understanding his characters and the worlds they inhabit, where moral choices and the nature of heroism are ever-present challenges.
Tolkien's legacy as a subcreator goes beyond mere storytelling; it encapsulates a philosophy of creativity that invites readers to engage with and reflect on the nature of their own realities through the lens of imaginative fiction. Through his elaborate world-building, he not only entertained but also provoked thoughtful discourse on the human condition, art, and the interplay of morality in a complex world.
We have come from God, and inevitably the myths we make, though they may be about dragons and not about gods, are about truth.
J.R.R. Tolkien
Concept of Subcreation
Subcreation is a term coined by J.R.R. Tolkien to describe the artistic process by which humans create new worlds, narratives, and forms of art that reflect and complement the primary creation by God. While God is the ultimate creator, Tolkien posits that humans engage in subcreation as a form of creative expression that mirrors the divine act of creation itself. This notion emphasizes a relational aspect between the creator and the created, wherein subcreators draw inspiration from the beauty of the existing world.
Philosophical Underpinnings
The concept of subcreation resonates with philosophical ideas found in the works of Plato and Aristotle, particularly concerning the search for ultimate wisdom and beauty, which, in Tolkien's worldview, stems from God. Tolkien's subcreation can be seen as an ongoing dialogue between the created world and human creativity, fostering an environment where new expressions of beauty can emerge. This interplay reflects a theological understanding that emphasizes the importance of the relationship between the Creator and His creations.
Definition and Interpretation
According to the Historical Dictionary of Science Fiction, subcreation is defined as "the action or process of creating a secondary world." This aligns with Tolkien's view that subcreation is not merely imitation, but an act of tending to the world, enhancing its beauty, and evolving the blessed blueprint that underpins it. This perspective also invites questions about the moral implications of subcreation: when does it become an act of pride or hubris, and how can it be seen as a form of worship?
The Music of the Ainur
A central theme in Tolkien's conception of subcreation is articulated through "The Music of the Ainur," which serves as a foundational myth for his legendarium. In this narrative, the Ainur, or holy spirits, create a harmonious world through a cosmic song, suggesting that music and creativity are intrinsic to the fabric of existence itself. This idea underscores the belief that each act of subcreation resonates with the divine, fostering an environment of beauty and enrichment.
Sanctified Subcreation
The idea of sanctified subcreation is particularly relevant, as it highlights the fertile relationship between humanity and the created world. Tolkien's diverse creation of races, languages, and histories showcases the expansive potential of subcreation, emphasizing that every soul possesses a creative spark capable of producing unique and diverse expressions. Thus, subcreation becomes not only a reflection of divine creativity but also a celebration of the inherent potential within every individual to contribute to the beauty of the world.
World Building
World building is a fundamental aspect of J.R.R. Tolkien's literary craft, allowing him to create an expansive and immersive universe that transcends mere storytelling. Tolkien popularized the concept of high fantasy through his intricate world of Middle-earth, which serves as a backdrop for his renowned works, including The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. His approach to world building is not only about crafting a narrative but also about establishing a rich mythology and a secondary world that reflects the moral and philosophical themes he wished to explore.
Methods of World Building
Tolkien's techniques in world building can be broadly categorized into two methods: top-down and bottom-up world building. Top-down world building involves starting with a general overview—such as the geography, climate, and history of the world—before moving into more detailed aspects like cultures, languages, and technologies. This method allows for a comprehensive understanding of the world's structure before diving into specific narratives. In contrast, bottom-up world building begins with
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Philosopheasy to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.