Georg Simmel's Philosophy of Money: How Currency Changes Your Soul
Have you ever felt a strange disconnect, a sense of being adrift in a sea of transactions? Do you find yourself constantly calculating, assessing, and quantifying, even in your personal relationships? It's not just about the price tag anymore, is it? It’s deeper, more pervasive. It touches something fundamental about who we are. What if this shift, this subtle erosion of the self, is not just a consequence of modern life but a direct result of the money we use?
This is precisely the question that occupied the brilliant, often-overlooked German sociologist and philosopher Georg Simmel. His groundbreaking work, The Philosophy of Money, published in 1900, isn’t just about economics. It’s a radical exploration of how money reshapes the human psyche, our relationships, and the very fabric of our culture. Buckle up, because this journey might change the way you look at your wallet… and yourself.
The Universal Solvent: How Money Intellectualizes Life
Simmel saw money as a “universal solvent.” It dissolves the particularities of things, reducing them to a single, abstract measure: their price. This seemingly simple concept has profound implications. Consider how you might choose a friend versus how you buy a coffee. One is personal, nuanced, based on shared experiences and unspoken understanding. The other? Primarily a transaction, defined by its monetary value.
Money, Simmel argued, fosters an “intellectualization” of life. We begin to see everything through the cold, objective lens of calculation. Emotions, values, and even love become susceptible to being weighed and measured, at least in our minds. Think about it: how often do you assess a potential purchase based on its “value”? The same calculation can subtly creep into our personal sphere. Are you consciously or unconsciously judging the “return” you’re getting on your emotional investments? The question is not, is money corrupting, but how has it made our experience more cold, even logical?
Want to learn more? Check out this excellent video that goes deeper into Simmel's ideas:
The Blasé Attitude: Emotional Numbness in a Monetary World
Constantly bombarded with the sensory overload of a modern, money-mediated world, Simmel observed a specific psychological response: the “blasé attitude.” This isn’t mere apathy. It's a defense mechanism, a way to navigate the relentless stream of stimuli that washes over us. The blasé individual becomes indifferent, jaded, and emotionally detached.
Imagine a world where everything is for sale, where every interaction has a price. How do you maintain a sense of wonder, of genuine feeling, when everything can be reduced to its monetary equivalent? The blasé attitude acts as a shield, protecting us from emotional exhaustion. But at what cost? Is this detachment a necessary survival tactic, or does it slowly erode our capacity for authentic experience?
“Money…is the most perfect expression of the indifference of things.” – Georg Simmel
The Paradox of Freedom: Bound by the System
Money offers unprecedented freedom. It frees us from the constraints of barter, from the obligations of personal relationships, from the limitations of geographical location. We can buy what we want, where we want, and when we want. But Simmel highlights a crucial paradox: this freedom creates a new form of dependence.
Money itself becomes the object of our desires, the new master. We become dependent on the monetary system, on earning, saving, and accumulating. We're no longer bound by the tangible obligations of feudal society, but by the abstract, all-encompassing logic of the market. Instead of owing a feudal lord, we can be forced to work for the global financial institutions or tech giants. This new master is all the more insidious because it appears benevolent, offering choice and opportunity while quietly dictating the terms of our lives.
Consider this: how much of your time and energy is spent chasing the next paycheck, the next investment, the next promotion? Is this truly freedom, or a new form of servitude?
From Personal Bonds to "Thing Bonds": The Transformation of Relationships
Before money's dominance, relationships were often based on personal ties, shared obligations, and direct exchanges. Money, however, fosters “thing bonds.” Instead of owing a debt of gratitude, we pay for a service, purchase a good, and move on. The personal connection is often severed, replaced by a cold, transactional relationship.
Think about the difference between buying from a local artisan and purchasing from a multinational corporation. One involves a direct connection, a sense of reciprocity. The other is a purely economic exchange. Even in relationships, how often do we quantify the “investment” we make? Is love becoming, in some ways, another transaction?
The reduction of the "other" to a mere means of exchange
The rise of rational individualism
The erosion of community and the weakening of social bonds
These consequences are all traceable to the influence of the "thing bonds" in a world ruled by money.
Beyond Price: The Blurring of Worth
Money, as a universal equivalent, makes it easy to equate price with worth. But are they the same? Simmel argues that this is a dangerous illusion. The price of something is determined by supply and demand, by market forces. Its true worth, however, is often intangible, based on intrinsic value, moral considerations, and personal meaning.
Think about art, for instance. Its monetary value can fluctuate wildly, yet its artistic merit remains constant. Or consider the value of a human life. Can it be assigned a monetary value? The blurring of price and worth can lead to a devaluation of non-monetary values, fostering a society obsessed with material wealth, perhaps at the expense of everything else.
Unlock deeper insights with a 10% discount on the annual plan.
Support thoughtful analysis and join a growing community of readers committed to understanding the world through philosophy and reason.
Conclusion: Reclaiming the Soul in a Monetary World
Georg Simmel's insights into the philosophy of money are more relevant than ever. He forces us to confront the uncomfortable truth: money isn’t just a tool; it’s a force that profoundly shapes our inner lives and the structure of society. Money shapes our experiences, our attitudes, and our very identities.
By understanding Simmel's concepts—the intellectualization of life, the blasé attitude, the paradox of freedom, the shift from personal to "thing bonds," and the blurring of price and worth—we can begin to navigate the monetary world with greater awareness. We can start to recognize how money influences our decisions, our relationships, and our sense of self. To reclaim control, to maintain our humanity in the face of relentless financialization, we must actively resist the homogenizing influence of money.
The path forward involves:
Cultivating a deeper appreciation for non-monetary values.
Nurturing authentic relationships based on shared experiences.
Resisting the allure of consumerism and the constant pursuit of wealth.
Fostering a critical awareness of the monetary system.
The work has just begun. The question is, what kind of world will we choose to build?
The choice, ultimately, is ours.