Susan Sontag (1933–2004) was a prominent American writer, philosopher, and cultural critic whose work profoundly influenced contemporary discourse on aesthetics, interpretation, and the role of art in society. Renowned for her essays and lectures, Sontag’s intellectual pursuits spanned literature, philosophy, and cultural studies, making her a central figure in 20th-century thought. Her seminal essays, particularly in the collection Against Interpretation and Other Essays (1966), challenged conventional approaches to art criticism, arguing for a direct engagement with aesthetic experience rather than a focus on content or allegorical meaning.
Sontag’s exploration of aesthetic experience emphasized the significance of form over content, advocating that art should be appreciated for its intrinsic qualities and emotional resonance. She argued that excessive interpretation diminishes the value of art, reducing it to mere intellectual exercise rather than a visceral experience. This perspective not only shifted the conversation around the appreciation of art but also influenced a broader cultural criticism that seeks to understand the complexities of modern art and its societal implications.
Notably, Sontag’s ideas on personal taste and “Camp” aesthetics posited that individual preferences play a crucial role in the engagement with art, suggesting that personal and cultural contexts significantly shape one’s artistic sensibilities. Her arguments highlighted the subjective nature of taste, challenging the notion of a monolithic cultural critique while advocating for a nuanced appreciation of art that transcends moral or ethical interpretations.
Throughout her career, Sontag faced controversies regarding her positions on various artistic movements and the ethical responsibilities of artists, often igniting debates about the interplay between art, culture, and societal values. Her legacy endures as a vital touchstone for contemporary discussions on the nature of art, the importance of aesthetic experience, and the complexities of interpretation, inviting ongoing exploration into how art enriches human understanding and experience.
Biography
Early Life
Susan Sontag was born on January 16, 1933, in New York City to a Jewish family of Lithuanian and Polish descent. She faced significant challenges in her early life, particularly after her father’s death from tuberculosis when she was just five years old. Following this loss, her mother took charge of raising Susan and her sister while frequently relocating, spending time in Arizona and California. This tumultuous environment contributed to Sontag’s feelings of isolation during childhood, exacerbated by her mother’s emotional detachment and alcoholism. Reading became her refuge, and by age 15, she graduated from North Hollywood High School.
Education
Sontag’s intellectual pursuits began in earnest during her adolescence. After high school, she attended the University of California, Berkeley, before transferring to the University of Chicago, where she majored in philosophy, literature, and history. At Chicago, she was influenced by prominent figures such as Leo Strauss and Kenneth Burke, and she graduated with an A.B. degree at just 18 years old, earning a spot in Phi Beta Kappa. Sontag continued her studies at Harvard University, obtaining master’s degrees in both English literature and philosophy by 1954, although she did not complete her Ph.D. dissertation.
Career Beginnings
In the late 1950s, after brief studies at Oxford University and the University of Paris, Sontag returned to New York City. There, she began her career in publishing and academia, initially working at the magazine Commentary. Her teaching career took off as she held positions at several prestigious institutions, including City College of New York, Sarah Lawrence College, and Columbia University between 1960 and 1964.
Literary Contributions and Philosophy
Throughout her life, Sontag was deeply engaged with literary and philosophical questions, continually exploring the role of the writer and the function of literature. She posited that while storytelling serves many noble purposes, the primary task of a writer remains to write well. Sontag emphasized the importance of storytelling in transforming information into wisdom, citing the responsibility of literature to illuminate and enhance human understanding. Her reflections on writing and culture culminated in powerful essays and public lectures, showcasing her commitment to both the craft of writing and the moral implications of literature.
Aesthetic Experience
Susan Sontag’s exploration of aesthetic experience emphasizes the significance of form over content in art. She argues that the completed work of art exists as an independent object, affirming its unique existence beyond the artist’s subjective view. This perspective highlights the aesthetic pleasure derived from the perceptual experience of form and style, suggesting that content is secondary and often absorbed into the form itself.
Sontag’s approach challenges the common misconception that content is the primary element of art. Instead, she posits that content serves merely as a vehicle to engage audiences in an aesthetic experience, where style becomes the focal point for both creation and appreciation. This paradigm shift encourages viewers to shift their focus from moral or ethical judgments to an evaluation of aesthetic qualities. For instance, Sontag uses the example of a Greek vase depicting the violent act of a warrior; its beauty is not contingent upon the moral implications of the scene it represents.
Furthering this discourse, Sontag critiques the tendency of viewers to confuse artistic works with ethical statements, urging that art should not be evaluated based on moral criteria. She asserts that the enjoyment of art is an aesthetic experience distinct from moral or ethical considerations. In doing so, she advocates for an “erotics of art” rather than a hermeneutics, arguing that the pleasure of experiencing art should take precedence over the need to interpret it through moral or allegorical lenses.
We have art in order not to die of the truth.
Friedrich Nietzsche
The nature of interpretation in the context of aesthetic experience can also be complex. Sontag’s ideas suggest that traditional interpretations often dig beneath the surface, seeking subtexts that may distort the original experience of the artwork. She argues for an understanding of art that recognizes its ability to evoke intense feelings and comprehension, which should not be conflated with a moral response to the content depicted.
Ultimately, Sontag’s vision of aesthetic experience promotes the idea that art should be appreciated for its intrinsic qualities, where the sensory and emotional reactions it elicits take precedence over moral or narrative evaluations. This perspective encourages a deeper engagement with art, fostering an appreciation for the unique ways in which it enhances our sensibility and enriches our lives.
Personal Taste
The Role of Taste in Aesthetic Experience
Susan Sontag’s exploration of personal taste is intricately linked to her broader discourse on aesthetic experience and cultural criticism. She posits that taste serves as a crucial component in the appreciation and understanding of art. According to Sontag, “Camp taste nourishes itself on the love that has gone into certain objects and personal styles,” indicating that a profound connection to art is often predicated on individual preferences and experiences. This notion implies that personal taste is not merely subjective but is informed by an intimate engagement with cultural artifacts.
Sontag’s perspective on taste aligns with the concept of “Camp Sensibility,” which she describes as a modern dandyism characterized by an aristocratic taste that transcends conventional sensibilities. She emphasizes that this taste is a form of aesthetic ability that not only includes but also surpasses basic sensory intuition. Thus, for Sontag, the appreciation of art involves a layered understanding that is deeply rooted in one’s cultural and personal context.
Taste is the only morality.
Oscar Wilde
The Interplay Between Sensibility and Interpretation
Sontag argues that our current cultural climate, saturated with interpretations, often leads to a diminished sensory experience of art. She critiques the tendency to prioritize interpretation over direct engagement with a work, suggesting that this habit dulls our perceptual faculties. “Ours is a culture based on excess, on overproduction; the result is a steady loss of sharpness in our sensory experience,” she states, underscoring the need to revive our senses to truly appreciate art.
Her call to recover sensory experiences highlights the essential role of personal taste in how individuals relate to art. By focusing on the immediacy of experience rather than interpretive frameworks, Sontag encourages a more nuanced engagement that celebrates the individuality of aesthetic appreciation.
The Subjectivity of Cultural Options
Sontag’s reflections also touch on the subjectivity inherent in cultural options, where the “soul” represents the intimate and personal experiences that shape one’s taste. She notes that personal preferences influence the interpretation of cultural artifacts, reinforcing the idea that taste is not monolithic but varies greatly among individuals. This variability is essential in understanding the broader implications of aesthetic judgment, as it emphasizes the importance of context and personal background in shaping one’s artistic sensibility.
Cultural Criticism
Modern Art and Aesthetics
Cultural criticism, particularly as articulated by Susan Sontag, focuses on the complexities of modern art and its reception. Sontag argues that the modern conception of art frequently involves systematic transgressions of formal conventions, which generates an aura of the unspeakable. Audiences often sense a negative presence of what could be articulated but is not, leading to interpretations that may overlook the intrinsic positivity of the artwork itself. She emphasizes that art should not merely be perceived as a statement or an expression of meaning but as an experience in its own right, highlighting the importance of style over content. Sontag critiques the tendency to reduce art to its meaning, suggesting that the viewer’s preoccupation with “what it means” detracts from the aesthetic experience that art offers.
The Role of Irony
Irony plays a significant role in the relationship between art and culture. While Sontag acknowledges that irony can serve as a coping mechanism for individuals, she cautions against its proliferation in social contexts where direct communication is paramount. Nietzsche’s observation that widespread irony signifies a cultural decline resonates with Sontag’s assertion that contemporary art is often seen more as “thought” than as art in the classical sense. This shift, she suggests, has implications for how we engage with
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Philosopheasy to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.